Skip to Content

Floor Statements

Floor Statement on the Graves Amendment to H.Res. 140, Providing for the Consideration of H.R. 3, the Transportation Equity Act: A Legacy for Users

Mr. Chairman, I thank the gentleman for yielding me time.


Mr. Chairman, the gentleman from Missouri says why should a company that rents a car to an individual, the company is not negligent, the individual is negligent, why should they be liable for the results of his or her negligence?


The answer is that is up to the State legislature. The State legislature may prefer that the person who must pay the medical bills should be the insurance company of the lessor company, rather than the innocent victim who is walking along with her baby stroller. We want people to be protected. There are cars that are insured to $10,000 and $20,000, they drive into a State with a high cost of living, with a high cost of medical care, that requires of its own domestic drivers $100,000 and $300,000, and there is no guarantee.


So the real answer is why should not New York or California or these other States be able to say we want to protect our citizens against non-resident drivers who are negligent, against foreign tourists from France who are negligent.


The real question is, should the insurance company bear the risk, the insurance company of the lessor company bear the risk, or should the woman with the baby stroller bear the risk? If I were running for the State legislature, I would say the insurance company. Here I say it is up to the legislature, not to us. Vote against this amendment.

Back to top